Jordin Sparks - Battlefield
10:31 AM Thursday Jul 30, 2009
Rating: * * *
If you're going to rip off an 80s icon, the least you can do is credit them for the inspiration.
Surely Jordin Sparks and her management realised people might notice the similarities between her sophomore album's title track Battlefield - complete with the lyrics "why does love have to feel like a battlefield. Battlefield. Battlefield" - and Pat Benatar's smash hit Love is a Battlefield. It's not the most subtle of plagiarism. And no, not a single liner note mentions Benatar.
It's not just the lyrics. Sparks' adopts the same defiant, call-to-arms style of Ms B. throughout the track.
It's actually a welcome change from the crooning, melodramatic rhythm 'n' pop she so specialises in: the type of music that begs lovelorn teenage girls to grab a hairbrush and lip synch along.
But even the over-the-top power ballad Don't Let It Go To Your Head and heartbroken wallow of No Parade are preferable to the breathy R&B fillers used to keep this record afloat between the radio hits.
Tattoo, One Step at a Time and Battlefield have already hit the Top 40, with more sure to follow - including the wannabe-Lady GaGa synthpop number S.O.S.
But in between the hits, Sparks reverts to reliable but lacklustre R&B that will have you lunging for the skip button. It's as if the young songstress hasn't quite decided what she wants to be - a dance pop princess or an urban diva. And though the two aren't mutually exclusive, Sparks is yet to pose a serious threat to Rihanna's reign over the genre.
Joanna Hunkin
I have the album and while I hoped for more I pretty much got what I expected.
Unfortunately it does seem to be a 'rushed' affair and it lacks any real direction.
There's a few 'OK' tracks, but I find the last half of the album to be the best - and alot of these tracks have actually been co-written by Jordin herself.
Hopefully come album number three she has more faith in her own abilities and leaves the hand-me-down tracks for some other pop puppet.
Interesting point to note: "Battlefield" was penned by the lead singer of "One Republic", Ryan Tedder.
He was also behind Leona Lewis's "Bleeding Love", Beyonce Knowles "Halo" (also originally intended for Leona) and he laid the backing track for Kelly Clarkson's "Already Gone" - which was also used for "Halo"!