nzherald.co.nz

Routines schmootines

By Dita De Boni
9:26 AM Monday Sep 8, 2008

Last night when my five and a half month old daughter woke up for the third time during the night, I found myself seriously questioning my parenting methods.

You see, I have never followed a stict routine with either child. They have been fed on demand - basically offered a breast whenever they seemed unhappy. If they don't want it, it's time for plan B - put them to bed. If not, it's a cuddle. And so on, all day - and all night - long.

No four hours counted between feeds, or two hours between sleeps. No clock watching at all really, except, I admit, my two-year-old goes to bed almost every night at 7pm. Being non-negotiable on this point has been the only way I've stayed sane!

I have read - and rejected - books by parenting gurus like Gina Ford, who advocate a very strict timetable of feeds, naps and other activities to get your baby settled into a somewhat predictable routine. This way of doing things admittedly seems to work for many women, and is often used by those wanting to re-enter the workforce and needing to get some structure to their hectic days.

Perhaps because I'm a stay at home mum I have the luxury of doing things as they happen. That's probably why I silently scoffed when I heard, when I was pregnant with number two, a colleague of mine suggest to another collegue that he tries to get his six-week-old baby into a four hourly routine (ie. only feed the baby at four hourly intervals, regardless of what the baby wants. An old fashioned idea that is now, seemingly, back in vogue).

I thought that was so crazy - until last night!

My daughter no longer needs breastfeeds during the night at all, and nevertheless, I seem to be able to hear her whimper through concrete walls, closed doors, long hallways, and any other possible audatory obstacle. I awake like one of Michael Jackson's living dead on his Thriller video, frequently waking sometime later to find myself breastfeeding her.

She's probably just turning over in her sleep, or she's just lost her dummy temporarily, or had a bad dream about milk. I should - as my husband suggests - just wait to see which way her simpering goes (up, in to full scale wail, or back down into silence). Unfortunately I can not, like him, just turn over and tune her out until she goes back to sleep. Every cry is like fingernails down the blackboard in my head.

Eventually, hopefully, my unbroken run of almost six nights without an uninterupted night's sleep will grind to an end. Hopefully that will be achieved when solids keep her full all night long. I draw the line at Gina Ford, but there's always, as a last resort, tying myself to the bed or knocking myself out with sleeping pills to inadvertenly teach my daughter to comfort herself through the night!

Dita De Boni

Photo / Andrew Bonallack

By Dita De Boni
good times (Spain) | 10:11AM Monday, 08 Sep 2008
Our four kids all were on a four hour schedule for feeding, but only because they chose it. I let them do as they pleased, and after about six weeks they naturally settled into it, the 10pm feed got them to 6am, and it just felt good obviously, to happen four times over. They knocked the 10pm feed on the head each at about 10-12 weeks, and continued with the four hourly feeds and nothing at night.

I just did what they wanted and then we worked around them. 10 weeks of muddle isn't much to ask really, once they were happy all was well in the home.

People with routines only have one more thing to worry over. Baby isn't feeding/sleeping to schedule, something is not right. But only on paper!
Mum for Life (New Zealand) | 10:17AM Monday, 08 Sep 2008
Routines are uneccessary the way I see it, made up for first time mums who need help becasue they are unsure of what do to. What to do is whatever you want for you and your baby, there is no right or wrong, so why try and sqeeze a baby into a schedule since everyone is different?

We had our boys all sleeping through 12 hours at three months by letting them do as they please, though we were getting eight hours sleep at two months old. We could go out with the babies whenever we wanted, no timetable to be confined to, and the babies where flexible, for small things like a trip to the market, to a long haul flight, eat and sleep anywhere. Worked a treat, we have four children and it worked from day one, now a long time ago, but I would recommend this system to anyone!
my2cents (Auckland Central) | 01:01PM Monday, 08 Sep 2008
I demand fed my first two as advised by plunket and it nearly drove me insane. My third started life in NICU so the first he knew was being woken every 3 hours for feeds and we continued this at home to keep him strong. Gradually winding out to 4 hourly. Nothing else was set in stone but he was fed every 4 hours even when that meant waking him up so he soon set his own naps to work around feeds and life has never been easier. I plan to do the same when son number four arrives but having seen others struggle I already know not every child will accept a routine. Personally I think its best to have a routine but have it based on the child's needs rather than what the book says.
Copyright ©2013, APN Holdings NZ Limited