John Armstrong 's Opinion

John Armstrong is the Herald's chief political commentator

John Armstrong: Let the voters punish the problem MP

46 comments
Prime Minister John Key. Photo / Mark Mitchell
Prime Minister John Key. Photo / Mark Mitchell

It is easy to identify the problem; finding the right solution is another matter altogether.

That is how the Prime Minister yesterday summed up the frustration of many MPs that a list member could be expelled from his caucus yet stubbornly still remain in Parliament as an independent MP.

John Key is right. There is general agreement across Parliament that - presuming Winston Peters is justified in dumping Brendan Horan - the latter should resign from Parliament.

One answer is to resurrect the long-expired law stopping MPs from jumping ship to other parties. The so-called "waka jumping" legislation passed by the Labour-Alliance coalition in 2001 did its job. But it had a "sunset clause" and expired in 2005.

On the urging of NZ First, Labour tried to revive the law late that year. But the measure eventually foundered for lack of numbers. National and the Greens opposed it.

The Prime Minister zeroed in on the essential dilemma: how do you write such a law to ensure the party leader could not use it to purge his or her caucus of malcontents or rivals for the top job.

Labour's failed bill stipulated that the leader would need the support of two-thirds of the caucus for any expulsion.

But the Greens argued that if MPs wished to oppose an expulsion, that meant they would effectively have to be prepared to roll the leader.

Much of MPs' unhappiness with Horan flows from him still picking up a big salary plus numerous expenses and other perks, thus reflecting badly on Parliament as a whole.

However, waka-jumper legislation is not the right answer. The democratic rights of genuine caucus rebels should not be sacrificed for the sake of expediency.

Better to do nothing. As Bill English noted back in 2005 during debate on Labour's second waka-jumping measure, any MP who became an independent was thrown out soon enough - by the voters.

"Those people are never seen again. That is pretty harsh punishment. They get dealt to."

That is something Horan will have to ponder over the holiday break.

- NZ Herald

John Armstrong

John Armstrong is the Herald's chief political commentator

Herald political correspondent John Armstrong has been covering politics at a national level for nearly 30 years. Based in the Press Gallery at Parliament in Wellington, John has worked for the Herald since 1987. John was named Best Columnist at the 2013 Canon Media Awards and was a previous winner of Qantas media awards as best political columnist. Prior to joining the Herald, John worked at Parliament for the New Zealand Press Association. A graduate of Canterbury University's journalism school, John began his career in journalism in 1981 on the Christchurch Star. John has a Masters of Arts degree in political science from Canterbury.

Read more by John Armstrong

Have your say

We aim to have healthy debate. But we won't publish comments that abuse others. View commenting guidelines.

1200 characters left

Sort by
  • Oldest

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf03 at 19 Dec 2014 15:04:26 Processing Time: 479ms