Matthew Backhouse

Matthew Backhouse is an APNZ news reporter based in Wellington.

NZ to introduce plain packaging of tobacco products

The Government is expecting legal challenges over plain cigarette packaging and has warned they could cost taxpayers up to $6 million.

Associate Health Minister Tariana Turia today announced the Government would push ahead with plans to introduce unbranded, standardised packaging with large health warnings for all tobacco products.

The plan would make New Zealand only the second country after Australia to introduce such packaging - but it would also make the Government vulnerable to legal challenges similar to those being fought across the Tasman.

Ms Turia said Ministry of Health officials would begin policy work immediately, but any changes would not be implemented until the conclusion of a World Trade Organisation dispute over Australia's introduction of plain packaging.

Ms Turia expected that could be completed within 18 months.

But the Government was likely to face legal challenges even if Australia won the WTO case - and Ms Turia said fighting off those challenges could cost taxpayers $3-$6 million.

Despite that, she was confident plain packs could be on shelves as soon as next year.

"We know that we've got trade obligations and we take them seriously ... but we are confident that plain packaging can be introduced consistently with those obligations."

However, Auckland University trade law expert Professor Jane Kelsey said the packaging changes might not go ahead at all.

She said waiting for all of Australia's legal cases to be concluded would push the Government's plans well into the next parliamentary term - when National might not have to rely on the Maori Party for support and would be free to abandon the law if it wanted to.

As well as the WTO case, Australia is being sued by tobacco giant Philip Morris on the grounds its packaging regime breaches a free trade agreement with Hong Kong.

Dr Kelsey said that process could take five years or more - by which time the tobacco companies would have "a whole new legal canvass on which to play" after the introduction of the Trans-Tasman Partnership Agreement.

Chapman Tripp partner Daniel Kalderimis said introducing plain packaging would result in big tobacco firms filing a slew of lawsuits - including potential administrative law challenges based on an alleged lack of consultation.

He said any legal challenges would be pursued vigorously by the tobacco firms, but they would face a complex job proving a breach of trade treaties.

British American Tobacco has already signalled it would not rule out legal action.

Its New Zealand general manager, Steve Rush, said the Government had been pragmatic in deferring its final decision until all the international trade and legal issues had been resolved.

"While we can't rule out legal action at this stage, we can say that we will fully participate in the legislative process."

Labour leader David Shearer and health lobby groups are among those in support of the plan.

Mr Shearer said it was the right thing to do.

"I think it's a good idea, it will benefit New Zealanders, it will have health benefits, bring down health costs."

Cancer Society spokeswoman Skye Kimura said the main aim was to protect children and tobacco products would no longer be decorated with desirable colours and prominent branding.

Smokefree Coalition director Prudence Stone said plain packaging would remove the tobacco industry's last methods of making smoking appear "glamorous and sophisticated" to children.

Action on Smoking and Health director Ben Youdan also praised the proposal, but said there was no need to delay its introduction until next year.

Mental Health Foundation chief executive Judi Clements said plain packaging could significantly reduce smoking and save the health system almost $2 billion.

- APNZ

© Copyright 2014, APN New Zealand Limited

Assembled by: (static) on red akl_a1 at 01 Aug 2014 10:26:12 Processing Time: 333ms