The winning strand is praised for its outstanding sand, writes Tamara Lush
The sand on Siesta Beach on Florida's Gulf Coast is as fine as powdered sugar, a pure, sparkling white and soft as a kitten's fur — all because it's comprised of 99 per cent pure crushed quartz.
For that reason, and many others, it was selected this year as the best beach in America by a professor who's made a career ranking and studying beaches around the United States.
"The sand is outstanding," said Stephen Leatherman, aka Dr Beach, a professor at Miami's Florida International University.
"Every time I go there, I've got to take a bag home with me. It's almost sacrilegious to walk on it with shoes on."
On a recent workday, Siesta Beach was packed with people, even though it wasn't particularly sunny. The turquoise water was still gorgeous, the sand still fine. The beach is about 60-90m wide in some places, which means people can stretch out and not feel crowded. It was last year's runner up and one of three in Florida on this year's top 10 list.
"It's nice and clean, that's what I look for," said Jamie Gaskin, a 59-year-old retiree from Lakeland, Florida, who was scoping out the beach for a family Memorial Day party. She especially liked the two-storey pavilion, which boasts a snack bar and toilets. It's only two years old and even offers sweet crepes for breakfast and tapas dishes in the early evening.
"There are plenty of tables to have barbecues and to hang out. And the restrooms were nice and clean. I'd definitely recommend this," she said.
Siesta Beach is on a barrier island in the Gulf of Mexico, and is just southwest of downtown Sarasota.
The water is placid most days — Leatherman says you can measure the waves "in inches" — and is shallow and safe for swimming, with no sharp drop-offs. Added bonuses include lots of parking, a trolley service to and from the island's adorable downtown area and plenty of lifeguards.
The beach also has natural dunes, a bit of a rarity for Florida, and the fine sand is excellent for building sand castles.
"I look for kind of a balance between nature and a developed environment," said Leatherman, who lives on the other side of the state, closer to Miami Beach.
"Fourteen million people go to Miami Beach every year. There's just too many people there. I think a lot of people are looking for more of a getaway."
Leatherman, director of the Laboratory for Coastal Research at Florida International University, has been ranking the beaches across the US for more than a quarter of a century. He uses about 50 criteria and in recent years has given extra points to beaches that prohibit smoking, saying cigarette butts are not only environmentally damaging, but can ruin the experience for beach-goers.
Safety and environmental management are other major factors, he said.
The Maui beach that came in at No. 2 on this year's list, Kapalua Bay Beach, is smaller than Siesta Beach. It's crescent-shaped and flanked by palm trees. Unlike many Hawaii beaches, there aren't many waves at Kapalua, Leatherman said, making it perfect for safe swimming.
"The coral reefs almost go right to the beach. There are fish swimming all around."
The third beach on the list, Ocracoke, is unique in both history and location. Leatherman points out that it was once the pirate Blackbeard's haunt. And it's only accessible by a state ferry.
"The only negative I have, it seems like too many cars," he said. "I wish they would turn car ferries to pedestrian ferries."
Leatherman says he tries to select locations that are a bit off the beaten path, yet immensely rewarding once visitors arrive. Siesta Beach, he points out, is an outstanding place to watch the sun dip below the Gulf horizon — one more reason why it was top of this year's list.
The top 10
Other beaches that made the list this year, in order of ranking, are:
2. Kapalua Bay Beach in Maui, Hawaii
3. Ocracoke Lifeguarded Beach on the Outer Banks of North Carolina
4. Grayton Beach State Park on the Florida Panhandle
5. Coopers Beach in Southampton, New York
6. Coast Guard Beach on Cape Cod in Massachusetts
7. Caladesi Island State Park in Dunedin/Clearwater, Florida
8. Hapuna Beach State Park, Big Island, Hawaii
9. Coronado Beach in San Diego, California
10. Beachwalker Park on Kiawah Island, South Carolina
Getting there: American Airlines flies daily from Auckland to Sarasota, Florida.